What is the osteological paradox and how does it influence the reputability of bioarchaeological studies?

The osteological paradox is a concept first addressed in a journal article by JW Wood and colleagues in 1992. It is concerned with the heterogeneity in disease risk, selective mortality, and demographic nonstationarity. We cannot discern the underlying vulnerabilities of a skeletal population, especially pertaining to intermingling of sub-populations, whether it may be undistinguishable due time depth or minor environmental differences. This is what is called hidden heterogeneity in risks. Selective mortality is basically the fact that the samples being studied are only of the dead people of specific ages. We, for instance, cannot study a living 15-year-old from a population 2,000 years ago, but only the 15 year olds who died when they were 15. Regarding age-at-death, nonstationarity populations are not affected by mortality rate changes and are increasingly affected by birth rate/fertility changes and more revealing of them. Basically, the main concern of the osteological paradox as it applies to the field of bioarchaeology and more specifically paleopathology, is that those who exhibit pathological lesions on the skeleton are a biased sample. For a disease to progress to the point of being present on bone, they would have had to survive with such a disease for some considerable amount of time, leaving the rest of the population with seemingly normal healthy looking skeletal remains to potentially be individuals who died from the disease at the onset of ‘contamination’ or early enough where it would not make itself present on bone. This concept is very influential on this field because the focus of paleopathological studies have switched from being individual based to population based. We are concerned with the population in bioarchaeology, and pathological analysis is a major asset of our research.

The original journal article by Wood et al (1992) was influential to the field of bioarchaeology since it’s publication. Most in the field understood the problems at hand, and so this publication resulted in a period of self-analysis and improvement of methods within bioarchaeology. As a result, this truly strengthened the subdiscipline. At the time of the publication, the reputability of bioarchaeological studies pertaining to paleopathology was not what it is today. Keep in mind that bioarchaeology is a fairly recent subfield of anthropology. Since publication, new methods have come about in bioarchaeology such as stable isotope analysis, which offers scientific data on diet, weaning, and migration that are beneficial for overcoming this paradox. There has been progress in population genetics and pathogen DNA analyses. Conclusively, the osteological paradox has made researchers become more reputable in fact, because of the desire to improve methods in bioarchaeology so as to avoid the osteological paradox and present factual data.

References:

  1. Cohen MN, Wood JW, Milner GR. 1994. The osteological paradox reconsidered. Curr Anthr 35(5):629-637.
  2. DeWitte, Sharon N & Stojanowski, Christopher M. 2015. The osteological paradox 20 years later: past perspectives, future directions. J Arch Res 23(4):397-450.
  3. Sieke, Thomas. 2013. The osteological paradox and issues of interpretation in paleopathology. Expl Anth 12(1). http://vav.library.utoronto.ca/index.php/vav/article/view/19464.
  4. Wood JW, Milner GR, Harpending HC, Weiss KM, Eisenberg LE, Hutchinson DE, Jankauskas R, Cesnys G, Katzenberg MA, Lukacs JR, McGrath JW, Roth EA, Ubelaker DH, Wilkinson RG. 1992. The osteological paradox: problems of inferring prehistoric health from skeletal samples {and comments and reply}. Curr Anth 33(4):343-370.
  5. Wright, Lori E & Yoder, Cassady J. 1992. Recent progress in bioarchaeology: approaches to the osteological paradox. J Arch Res 33(4):343-370.

What is taphonomy and why is it important to the various sub-fields of biological anthropology?

Greek roots of Taphonomy: taphos (burial) + nomos (laws) = the laws of the grave.

The term taphonomy was originally defined by a Russian paleontologist named I.A. Efremov, in 1940, as the study of the remains of animals as they transition from the biosphere to the lithosphere. The concept was adopted by zooarchaeologists, and then subsequently adopted by ‘normal’ archaeologists. Archaeology’s definition of taphonomy does not relate to Efremov’s original definition. To archaeologists, the focus of taphonomy was not on organic remains, but of material culture and the effects the natural environment had on these artifacts.  Taphonomy actually includes both cultural and natural transforms on ORGANIC REMAINS. Originally, the focus on taphonomy was to suss out the processes that affected the remains to better evaluate the remains. Now, taphonomy is important for both this aspect and also to understand taphonomy for taphonomy’s sake.

Both of these aspects of taphonomy are extremely important to forensic anthropology. After we die, our body goes through various stages of decomposition and foreign ‘visitors’ feed on our bodies and ‘set up shop’ so to speak. These visitors range from bacteria, to fly larvae, to beetles, to large carnivores. To better understand ‘burial taphonomy’ regarding the processes of human decomposition, various anthropology departments have created facilities called “body farms”, the original belonging to the University of Tennesee-Knoxville. FAC_logoThe knowledge obtained from these body farms are important aspects in solving forensic cases.

The first time taphonomy became a part of archaeology was related to paleoanthropology. Researchers in this field used taphonomy to be able to differentiate between cultural and natural modifications of hominid bone, which is extremely important. For example, the Guattari Cave in Italy was reported to have Neandertal skeletal remains indicative of ‘ritual cannibalism’. Recent studies of these skeletal remains and of the site came to a different conclusion. They reported that there weren’t any indications of cannibalism on the bones, but rather cut marks left by animals, particularly hyenas. At this site, hundreds of animal bones were found consistent with what is found in modern hyena dens. This isn’t the only site where evidence of cannibalism on hominin remains were refuted, and some sites incite lively debates on the subject matter. Taphonomy is important to paleoanthropology, a sub-field of biological anthropology, because it can reveal truths and negate notions regarding the natural and cultural processes after deposition, which in turn can inform us about the practices and environments of various hominins.

Taphonomy is also important to bioarchaeology. Since taphonomy also includes cultural processes of human remains, we can learn things such as ritual violence.

Image-2_Taphonomy
Sacrum exhibiting taphonomic color differentiation

Unfortunately, the literature for taphonomy as it applies to biological anthropology (aside from forensic applications) is limited, and so strong hypotheses and inferences are thus also limited because the lack of literature means that bioarchaeologists cannot pull from multiple lines of evidence for interpretation of cultural taphonomy. It is also important to note that taphonomy is linked to the local ecology, and therefore more literature regarding location specific taphonomic factors as they apply to human remains will also be beneficial for biological anthropologists, especially forensic anthropologists working on foreign mass disaster sites.

References:

  1. Bone Broke. 2014. Sussing out site taphonomy: understanding formation processes in the Sonoran Desert. WordPress. https://bonebrokeblog.wordpress.com/2014/02/13/sussing-out-site-taphonomy-understanding-formation-processes-in-the-sonoran-desert/.
  2. Costandi, Mo. 2015. Life after death: the science of human decomposition. The Guardian. http://www.theguardian.com/science/neurophilosophy/2015/may/05/life-after-death.
  3. Duhlig, C. 2003. Forensic anthropology: non-forensic remains: the use of forensic archaeology, anthropology, and burial taphonomy. Sci Just 43(4):211-214.
  4. Lyman, R Lee. 2010. What taphonomy is, what it isn’t, and why taphonomists should care about the difference. J Taph 8(1):1-16. https://anthropology.missouri.edu/~anthro/sites/default/files/2010%20what%20taph%20is.pdf.
  5. Perez, Ventura R. 2012. The taphonomy of violence: recognizing variation in disarticulated skeletal assemblages. Int J Paleoanth 2(3):156-165.

How and when should forensic techniques be applied in the American justice system?

I have previously established that forensic techniques are subject to error and are not uniform in reliability, and therefore I deem this is a viable question that warrants attention. A ‘new forensics’ is arising in present day that is more scientific in nature, but different issues accompany this second generation of forensic science. Though these new methods are scientifically relevant and more reliable than traditional methods, they are more expensive and require expertise. The traditional methods, such as hair analysis and bite mark analysis, have been consistently deemed un-scientific and subjective in the literature. It is important to keep in mind that these traditional methods are usually regarded as supplementary to a case, where defendant testimony and eyewitness accounts were the main focus in the American justice system. This is largely in part to the fact that these traditional methods have limits in their application. For instance, you need a bite mark on a victim to conduct bite mark analysis, but not every case of assault or murder will have accompanying bite marks on the victim.

Media plays a role in all of this as well, and it’s called the ‘CSI Effect’. This is where television shows like NCIS and CSI glamorize forensic techniques as scientific and irrefutable forms of evidence that always crack the code and put perpetrators behind bars. It’s important to note that the American justice system has this thing..called a jury. The jury is comprised of ‘unbiased’ laypeople, and its safe to say that many in the jury watch these crime scene television shows, and so when an expert, such as a forensic odontologist, comes to the stand, they will believe this odontologist’s evidence to be an empirical hard science (as such crime scene shows depict it). Traditional forensic science seems to be a pseudoscience that has wrongly placed innocent individuals behind bars. It does not have a place in the American justice system as it presently exists. Recently, the FBI and Justice Department have come out to say that almost every forensic examiner provided erroneous data in trial from the 1970s to 2000.  This is the largest review of forensic evidence to date, and is also disheartening to hear about. It is even more disheartening to hear that in this review they have found that 32 individuals on the death penalty were wrongly accused, and 14 of these individuals have already died. The main forensic technique under review in this study is microscopic hair evidence. I became irate whenever I found out an individual found innocent from this three year re-visitation/review and served 28 years for a murder he did not commit based on hair analysis, only to determine that one of these hairs on trial actually came FROM A DOG.

It’s blatantly obvious that there is a lack of essential peer review in forensic sciences. This is, in part, to due non-scientist run accredited labs. There is promise with the second generation forensic techniques, because only scientists can conduct these analyses such as DNA typing (due to the difficulty and knowledge needed). This would also open doors for outside help, such as universities. This would increase accuracy, peer reviewed publishing, and reduce cost.

With all that I have stated, I have come to the conclusion that forensic techniques should be applied on a case by case basis cautiously if necessary at all. From the evidence I have brought forth, I conclude that second generation forensic techniques should be applied in the American justice system more frequently than traditional methods. Traditional methods need to be nationally revised before being implemented as a ‘science’, because science is empirical and objective, and therefore these traditional methods are not science.

References:

  1. Gabel, Jessica D. 2014. Realizing reliability in forensic science from the ground up. J Crim Law Crimn 104(2):283-352.
  2. Howes, Loene M. 2015. The communication of forensic science in the criminal justice system: A review of theory and proposed directions for research. Sci Just 55(2):145-154.
  3. Lithwick, Dahlia. 2015. Pseudoscience in the witness box: The FBI faked an entire field of forensic science. Slate. http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/jurisprudence/2015/04/fbi_s_flawed_forensics_expert_testimony_hair_analysis_bite_marks_fingerprints.html.
  4. Murphy, Erin. 2007. The new forensics: criminal justice, false certainty, and the second generation of scientific evidence. Calif Law Rev 95(3):721-797.
  5. Shahani, Aarti. 2011. Casey Anthony trial shows the limits of forensic science in proving how a child died. Pro Publica. http://www.propublica.org/article/casey-anthony-trial-shows-the-limits-of-forensic-science-in-proving-how-a-c.
  6. Simmross, Ulrich. 2014. Appraisal of scientific evidence in criminal justice systems: on winds of change and coexisting formats. Law Prob Risk 13(2):105-115.
  7. Smith, Jordon Michael. 2014. Forget CSI: a disaster is happening in America’s crime labs. Business Insider. http://www.businessinsider.com/forensic-csi-crime-labs-disaster-2014-4.

How reliable are biometrics (fingerprints, body shapes, hair analysis, bite marks, DNA)?

The short answer to this is: it depends. This may sound like a cop-out, but the success rates depend on what form of biometric recognition. For those of you unfamiliar with this term, biometrics are the documented or recognized individual biological and behavioral attributes.

In the United States, a criminal register is preserved that contains soft biometrics, such as hair color and eye color as well as individual measurements and their fingerprints. Pictured: Blank fingerprint card
In the United States, a criminal register is preserved that contains soft biometrics, such as hair color and eye color as well as individual measurements and their fingerprints. Pictured: Blank fingerprint card

Fingerprint analysis is the more commonly utilized biometric analysis. This is likely because the law requires convicted criminals to provide their fingerprints to law enforcement, which is subsequently kept on a criminal register and this has been the standard procedure since 1924. The main issue in this analysis is that most of the fingerprints left at the crime scene are partial prints, which make it difficult to compare to the register or the fingerprints of potential perpetrators.

Hands down, DNA sampling is the king of biometrics. Even though it is the most reliable, there are still some pertinent issues. First and foremost, DNA profile matching is dependent on two factors: time and comparable DNA. Standard procedure for DNA profiling is PCR analysis, where a DNA sample is amplified so that it may be more easily studied. Some minor fall-backs are that cosmos-dnathis analysis takes up to several hours and is prone to error and erroneous mutations. Since 2013, police are now able to take DNA samples of individuals who are arrested. This was a very important leap for criminal investigations, because it creates a database much similar to the fingerprint register.

Some biometric analyses are not founded in scientific inquiry however, such as bite mark analysis. The serial killer Ted Bundy was found guilty from bite mark analysis employed by a forensic odontologist (dentist). They were able to match his unique tooth morphology to a bite mark on a victims skin. After this infamous case, bite mark analysis became an eminent forensic biometric analysis. Bite mark analysis is not useful in all scenarios, and is most useful in child abuse cases, because the it significantly lowers the number of individuals who could have created the bite mark on the victim.

Ted Bundy. Caught in Pensacola, FL.
Ted Bundy. Caught in Pensacola, FL.

Bite mark analysis is subjective and human skin is affected in human decomposition which can distort the bite mark. Cadaver research has also suggested that bite mark analysis is not uniform and the same teeth can create different impressions on the skin.

It was surprising to find out that, aside from DNA, most of the biometric analyses are not scientifically founded and empirically tested. The reliability of various methods really depend on the crime itself, and these analyses would thus become more reliable if empirical testing was done. There is hope however. The reliability of eyewitness accounts are dependent upon distance, and a study exists which is an example of empirical and scientific research. A study has been conducted recently that found distance is equal to blurriness and now photos are able to be blurred accordingly to the witness statements when a distance is recalled for a more successful ID.

References:

  1. Hopkins, Kathleen. 2014.Bite-mark evidence not always accurate. USA Today. http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/02/10/bite-mark-evidence-sometimes-wrong/5372523/.
  2. Jain, Anil K & Ross, Arun. 2015. Bridging the gap: from biometrics to forensics. Phil Trans Roy Soc 370(1674):1-10.
  3. Live Science Staff. 2005. The real crime: 1,000 errors in fingerprint matching every year. LiveScience. http://www.livescience.com/9341-real-crime-1-000-errors-fingerprint-matching-year.html.
  4. Lloyd, Robin. 2005. False ID: facial recognition on trial. LiveScience. http://www.livescience.com/6897-false-id-face-recognition-trial.html.
  5. Nidlova, Veronika & Hart, Jan. 2015. Reliability of identification based on fingerprints in dual biometric identification systems. Appl Mech Mat 752:1040-1045.
  6. Shaw, Danny. 2015. Can we still rely on DNA sampling to crack crime? BBC. http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-32546183.

How reliable is facial reconstruction?

6a0120a5580826970c0120a5aa4623970b-800wi
The “Angelator”: holographic implement on the fictional TV series ‘Bones’ that shows the physical appearance of an individual using craniometrics.

The first scientific facial reconstruction was done by Wilhelm Itisen in 1895; he utilized measurements of tissue depth thickness from German cadavers to reconstruct the face of Bach. In present day, facial reconstruction is applied in both forensics and archaeology, and some of the methods employed by Itisen are still in use today. Skepticism exists in the biological anthropology community, especially as it pertains to archaeological human remains. This question is particularly inquiring about the reliability of facial reconstruction as it applies to forensics however, and that is only what will be discussed in this response. Outright, I have found enough evidence to support that forensic reconstruction is not entirely reliable (particularly in terms of positive identification) and should be used as a supplementary aid in a forensic investigation when all other avenues have been exhausted. First and foremost, there are glaring limitations in predicting facial soft tissue on dry bone alone. In general anatomy, it is taught that many of the facial muscles are not directly associated with the bone. Some may have one attachment site to bone, but the other attachments are associated with other soft tissue. The only two muscles whose attachments remain visible on the skull in (almost) every instance are the masseter and temporalis.  temporalis-and-masseterThe figure to the left identifies these two muscles and their origins and insertions. This fact alone blows the idea that facial reconstruction is an even combination of science and art away. The error rates are high for determining mouth width and nose projection, which are two very important aspects of a human face. If most of the facial muscles are not directly evident on bone, than much is left to the interpretation of the facial reconstruction sculptor/artist. Facial reconstructions were employed for the victims of the Bali bombings in 2002, and 50% of these reconstructions were inaccurate because they were wrongly identified. The main guidelines used in facial reconstruction are not founded on empirical evidence, and some date back to the late 1800’s (the time of Wilhelm Itisen). The guidelines and techniques are not uniform in facial reconstructions either and determining which to use is up to the artist.

Facial Reconstruction of King Richard III.
Facial Reconstruction of King Richard III.

Three main techniques exist and these are the Russian anatomical method, the American anthropometrical method, and the Manchester method which utilizes the combination of the Russian and American methods. The results of accuracy rates of these three methods are not uniform, some researchers claiming a 100% accuracy rate and others claiming a 70% accuracy rate for one particular method.

Individuals that do facial reconstructions are quick to point out that these reconstructions are not expected to positively identify an unidentified individual, but are done to aid in the investigation by generating leads or a tentative ID. As it turns out, facial reconstruction is not too reliable at all. Because of this, a more suitable term for facial recognition should be employed, such as facial approximation, because the term recognizes the error or general inaccuracies in this forensic technique.

References:

  1. Lee WJ, Wilkinson CM, Hwang HS. 2012. An accuracy assessment of forensic computerized facial reconstruction employing cone-beam computed tomography from live subjects.J Foren Sci 57(2):318-327.
  2. Phillips, Vincent M. 2001. Skeletal remains identification by facial reconstruction. Foren Sci Comm 3(1).
  3. Stephan, Carl N & Henneberg, Maciej. 2001. Building faces from dry skulls: are they recognized above chance rates? J Foren Sci 46(3):432-440.
  4. Stephan, Carl N. 2003. Anthropological facial ‘reconstruction’ – recognizing the fallacies, ‘unembracing’ the errors, and realizing method limits. Sci Just 43(4):193-200.
  5. Wilkinson, Caroline. 2010. Facial reconstruction – anatomical art or artistic anatomy? J Anat 216(2):235=250.

What is “effective altruism” and how can anthropological perspectives be used to inform it?

To define effective altruism, I must first define altruism. Altruism is the act of selflessly helping another organism (in this case human) in need, even if the act has the potential to place the ‘aid’ in a dangerous situation. Effective altruism is an extension of human altruism, where only the most effective means of providing aid to others are considered. In a way, effective altruism is a movement, albeit a primarily monoculturally inclined movement. Peter Singer is the chief proponent of this movement as well as the spearhead of the website “The Life You Can Save” which is also the title of a book he wrote.

As I have stated before, this movement is monocultural, meaning that it exists primarily of individuals of a high or middle economic standing in a developed nation. How can anthropological viewpoints enlighten this movement? Anthropology can be informative in understanding altruism from an evolutionary and biological standpoint, as well as be informative about the consideration of cultural relativism. Both hunter-gathering groups and studies of children point to altruism being inherent in the human condition. Altruism seems that it is connected with sexual selection and reproductive fitness, or fitness in general in cases of reciprocal altruism. Reciprocal altruism is where being altruistic will be beneficial by the act being returned in the future. Also, effective altruism would be the most effective if there was awareness about the morals and cultural practices of the specific group in need.

References:

  1. Cela-Conde CJ, Burges L, Nadal M, Olivera A. 2010. Altruism and fairness:Unnatural selection? Comp Ren Biol 333(2):174-180.
  2. Manoj, VR. 2007. Cyborgs and Altruism. Institute for Ethics & Emerging Technologies. Ethical Technology. http://ieet.org/index.php/IEET/more/1696/.
  3. Meredith, Richard. 2015. Why Peter Singer is wrong about ‘effective altruism’. Pro Bono. http://www.probonoaustralia.com.au/news/2015/07/why-peter-singer-wrong-about-%E2%80%98effective-altruism%E2%80%99#
  4. Singer, Peter. 2013. The why and how of effective altruism. TED Talks. English. https://www.ted.com/talks/peter_singer_the_why_and_how_of_effective_altruism?language=en.
  5. Singer, Peter. 2015. The logic of effective altruism. Bost Rev 40(4):14-31.
  6. Szalavitz, Maia. 2012. Is human nature fundamentally selfish or altruistic? TIME Magazine. http://healthland.time.com/2012/10/08/is-human-nature-fundamentally-selfish-or-altruistic/.

What will our bodies look like 2,000 and 200,000 years from now?

The pre-eminent view is that human evolution has reached a plateau and we will no longer experience macroevolution. How then can you explain the rapid micro evolutionary occurrences within the past 10,000 years of our existence on this planet? Geneticists have been able to locate over 2,000 genetic adaptations ranging from immunity genes to adaptations of the brain that have occurred within the past 10,000 years. Why has there been such an increase in genetic adaptation? John Hawkes and other researchers suggest that it’s because of the rapid growth of human population. Seven percent of our genetic makeup comes from recent adaptations, such as lactase persistence, blue eye color, and especially the Duffy blood type related to malaria prevention.

It’s very difficult to pinpoint what might happen to our appearance 2,000 and 200,000 years from now because of the current strides in neuroscience, genetics, technology, and space exploration. Therefore, from hereon out I will only discuss speculations of potential avenues that our species might face.

In 20,000 years, putting neuroscience and technology aside, some researchers predict that we will have larger foreheads to accommodate a larger brain. They also predict that in the span of 100,000 years from now we will have darker skin pigmentation on average, thicker eyelashes, and larger superciliary arches (brow ridges) in relation to space exploration and colonization of other planets. Though, I’m a little skeptical about this prediction because we have absolutely no idea what is going to happen in the next 100,000 years and we also don’t know how our bodies would fare in the solar system aside from what we know based on NASA astronauts. It is also predicted that there will be a ‘mastery’ of morphological characteristics, like facial symmetry and intense eyes that will be larger than they are today.

Another angle to look at in predicting our appearance is genomic engineering. It is predicted that by 2100 we will know everything there is to know about the human body and its systems.  01125107.Par.89380.ImageFileIf designer babies and gene therapy become an easily accessible reality, humankind will reflect human ideals and will be able to avoid crippling illness. There are also developments in immortality studies, where researchers are looking at telomeres in immortal animals like jellyfish, bone stem cells, and immortal cancer cells to better understand the potential for longevity and eventually immortality. In 2013, there were over 1996 clinical trials of gene therapy.

One of my favorite avenues to discuss is cybernetic immortality proposed by a Russian billionaire named Dmitry Itskov. His organization, the 2045 Initiative, is a team of neuroscientists, robotics experts, and specialists in artificial systems and organs. By 2020, Itskov hopes to create a robot controlled by the human brain and five years after that to be able to successfully transplant a recently deceased human’s brain into an avatar or humanoid robot. By 2035, he plans to be able to upload a human personality to a computer and finally by 2045, the ultimate goal is to transport human consciousness and create a hologram entity with the disembodied consciousness.

100817533-100559335-milestones_en_r.530x298

If our species were to take the natural course, we would certainly continue to evolve. There is however no general consensus on what will happen to our appearance 2,000 and 200,000 years from now. We could be large eyed freaks, conscious holograms, or not even exist. That’s the exciting part about the future: it is unpredictable.

References:

  1. Appleyard, Brian. 1998. Brave new worlds: Staying human in the genetic future. Viking: New York. https://www.nytimes.com/books/first/a/appleyard-brave.html.
  2. Baltimore D, Berg P, Botchan M, Carroll  D, Charo RA, Church G, Corn JE, Daley GQ, Doudna JA, Fenner M, Greely HT, Jinek M, Martin GS, Penhoet E, Puck J, Sternberg SH, Weissman JS, Yamamoto KR. 2015. A prudent path forward for genomic engineering and germline gene modification. Science 348(6230):36-38.
  3. Dillow, Clay. 2012. Will people alive today have the opportunity to upload their consciousness to a new robotic body? Popular Science. http://www.popsci.com/technology/article/2012-03/achieving-immortality-russian-mogul-wants-begin-putting-human-brains-robots-and-soon.
  4. Enriquez, Juan & Gullans, Steve. 2015. With gene therapy we could direct our own evolution. Discover Magazine. http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/crux/2015/03/09/gene-therapy-direct-evolution/#.Vje_7FzgKlI.
  5. Hawkes, John. 2007. Why human evolution accelerated. John Hawkes Weblog. http://johnhawks.net/weblog/topics/evolution/selection/acceleration/accel_story_2007.html.
  6. McAuliffe, Kathleen. 2009. They don’t make Homo sapiens like they used to. Discover Magazine. http://discovermagazine.com/2009/mar/09-they-dont-make-homo-sapiens-like-they-used-to.
  7. Miller, Lantz. 2014. Is species integrity a human right? A rights issue emerging from individual liberties with new technologies. Hum Right Rev 15(2):177-199.
  8. Olson, Parmy. 2013. How the human face might look in 100,000 years. Forbes. http://www.forbes.com/sites/parmyolson/2013/06/07/how-the-human-face-might-look-in-100000-years/.
  9. Saniotos, Arthur. 2009. Future brains: An exploration of human evolution in the 21st century and beyond. Wor Fut Rev 1(3):5-11.

Are we already cyborgs thanks to technology?

An aerospace inventor and medical doctor coined the term cyborg in 1960 as a hybrid between an organism and its technology, which provides the organism extrasomatic capabilities otherwise not achievable without the technology. Humans are a unique species in that we have always modified the environment around us to survive and adapt; we were able to become more successful in the events central to survival, such as hunting. We have been able to extend our physical selves by our modifications for thousands of years. Only recently have we achieved a way to extend the mental self: through technology.

A lot has come out of this current technological age, especially in the fields of medicine and geriatrics. Aside from medical electronic implements (such as pace makers), there are still technological implements in the general populace that would deem us to be cyborgs. The cell phone as it exists today is an excellent example of this. With the cell phone, particularly smart phones, we have access to the entire web, our friends, our family, GPS, health trackers, music, videos, and social networking and media. Because of this accessibility, we have become reliant on our smartphones (I know I am guilty of this). tumblr_mdwty2RQL01rz819ro4_250Amber Case, a prominent cyborg anthropologist, believes that through this technology and accessibility we have been able to compress time and space. These capabilities are not achievable without this technology, which goes back to the original definition of cyborg (that Amber Case also quotes as the definition of cyborg). Because of this accessibility, social networking has exploded. It’s almost eerie to think about, but our profiles and Internet footprint serve as a second self, or a virtual extension of our self. Our friends are able to interact with our second self when we are not there, we are able to share our feelings and opinions on these sites and share articles to read later, and we also can virtually check into places like restaurants or stores. Because of this reliance on technology, we fall victims to things such as junk sleep or connective obligation. KrT7lJunk sleep is where REM sleep is not attained because of smart phone usage before bed. Social networking sites are formatted to provide snippets of content into our brains, which tricks our brains into becoming more active. Connective obligation stems out of the accessibility of our mobile technologies; we feel obligated to answer others through email, social networking, calls, and text messages because we have the accessibility to do so at any given moment.

Some believe that we are in the “archaic” period of cyborg-ism, because the more accessible technologies still have screens and we are limited in our abilities because of this. However, as technology advances, more accesible technologies will come about that will result in the ‘age of calm technology’, where we will be able to focus on our external environment again without being glued to a screen.

Here is a list of various technologies available to us/becoming available to us in the near future (but not currently easily accessible) that have the potential to further the process of becoming cyborgs:

  1. Bionic Eye
  2. Epidermal Circuits
  3. Brain Implant
  4. Google Glasses
  5. Continous Flow Device
  6. Vibrotactile Glove
  7. Parasitic Humanoid
  8. Animated Bio-luminescent Tattoos
  9. Smart Watches

References:

  1. Case, Amber. 2010. We are all cyborgs now. TED Talks. English. http://www.ted.com/talks/amber_case_we_are_all_cyborgs_now?language=en
  2. Hallet, Alison. 2013. The illustrated dictionary of cyborg anthropology explains how we’re all part machine. Wired. http://www.wired.com/2013/02/cyborg-anthropology/
  3. Martin, Glen. 2014. Don’t worry, we’re already cyborgs. Forbes Tech. http://www.forbes.com/sites/oreillymedia/2014/02/19/i-cyborg/.
  4. Verbeek, Peter-Paul. 2008. Cyborg intentionality: Rethinking the phenomenology of human technology—technology relations. Phren Cog Sci 7(3):387-395.
  5. Wells, Joshua J. 2014. Keep calm and remain human: How we have always been cyborgs and theories on the technological present of anthropology. Rev Anth 43(1):5-34.

Who is involved at the end of life, and is their role biological, cultural, or both?

Death is a human universal and we will all experience it someday. Some deaths are sudden, but others are expected. For those expected deaths, the roles seem to correlate particularly with individuals in hospital settings. Modern medicine has afforded us opportunities to extend life further when faced with a chronic progressive or degenerative illness, through avenues such as hospice care, drugs, and life support equipment. Because of this, there has been an incentive of health care professionals to implement end-of-life care. death  So far, only around 6,500 doctors are certified to practice end-of-life, or palliative, care. The primary focus of most physicians is the disease itself and the cure. Therefore, the general role of the doctor is biological for the majority. Nurse practitioners and hospital chaplains are more dynamic in their roles and are also involved with end-of-life care. Nurse practitioners are involved biologically and culturally in end-of-life care. They assist the doctor with medicine and medical procedure, but also assist the families in coping with such a difficult time. Chaplains exist in hospital settings for multiple reasons. They are there to discuss death in a more spiritual light for patients who request it. They are also there to help dying patients with difficult situations and to help with disagreements and conflicts between the dying patients family and the medical facility. Chaplains do not exist for Christianity exclusively, there are chaplains of various religions or cultural backgrounds (Muslim, Buddhist, religious-symbols_2 sodahead comJewish, and Hindu to name a few). Their role is purely cultural. If the individual had family, they too generally will be involved at the end of life. Their role is also dynamic in that they are biologically related to the individual, but the concept intimacy and closeness of biological relations is purely cultural. Financial matters are also important, and so lawyers can also be involved with the end of an individual’s life. Modifying the will, and discussing options isn’t biological in the slightest.

Pre-need funeral salesmen might also be involved at the end of somebody’s life. They exist so that individuals can purchase their funeral, or a portion of it, as well as cemetery plots and markers. This role is entirely cultural, because death is an industry in present day. Not only is it an industry, it is an expensive industry. Individuals aware of their mortality, particularly those hospitalized from a chronic degenerative illness whose days are numbered do not want to burden their family with the high costs related to their death and funeral and therefore utilize these pre-need plans. After an individual dies, either the doctor or a medical examiner observes the body and a death certificate is issued for the recently deceased individual. After this, the decision is generally left to the next of kin, but federal and state regulations can limit what is done to the body after a death certificate is issued, but the more common step is to have the body be transported to a funeral home, have a funeral service, and either be embalmed and buried or cremated.
References:

  1. Bradby H, Kenten C, Deedat S, Morgan M. 2013. Having a different conversation around death: diverse hospital chaplains’ views on end-of-life care. Ethn Heal 18(6):530-543.
  2. Hardling, Richard & Higginson Irene J. 2014. Inclusion of end-of-life care in the global health agenda. Lancet Glob Healt 2(7): 375-376.
  3. Jenkins, William O. 2012. State regulation of the death care industry varies and officials have mixed views on need for further federal involvement. GAO Rep 103-105.
  4. Schafer, Cyril. 2012. Corpses, conflict, and insignificance? A critical analysis of post-mortem practices. Mortal 17(4):305-321.
  5. Virdun C, Luckett T, Davidson PM, Phillips J. 2015. Dying in the hospital setting: a systematic review of quantitative studies identifying the elements of end-of-life care that patients and their families rank as being most important. Pall Med 29(0):774-796.

Who controls the dead?

After an individual dies, a transition occurs where the deceased changes from person to object. In modern America, there is an associated process with the ‘death industry’. In present day, most deaths occur in hospital settings and most hospitals contain morgues, where these recently deceased individuals are carted away to. After examination by a licensed medical examiner, a death certificate is issued. What is supposed to happen next is up to the family, but some states have laws that extensively limit what can occur. For instance, nine states in America force families to hire licensed funeral directors. Michigan for example requires authorization of a death certificate by both a medical examiner and a licensed funeral director. Who in the family has a say on what happens to the deceased? Generally, this is the spouse, but if the deceased individual did not have a spouse, this is determined on a case by case basis. The funeral industry would want you to believe that they are the ones who should be tasked with controlling the dead, but this is not the case and the permeance of the funeral industry hasn’t always been so involved in the death process. Deceased individuals would be kept at home after death in the 17th and 18th centuries in the US, where they would be cleaned and cared after by family members.

Embalming Ad
Embalming Ad

It was not until embalming came about in the 20th century, that we see a shift in who controlled the dead.  Along with embalming, came this notion that the dead body was this sickening and contaminating thing. From these two concepts, sprung the funeral industry and it has been the primary caretaker of the dead in the United States. Within the last ten years, small corners of American media have been becoming more death ‘positive’. There are about fifty burial sites that allow green burials, there have been TED talks on alternative disposal methods, book’s such as Caitlyn Doughty’s on life in the death industry, and events like Death Cafes. We are starting to see the beginnings of a shift back

Organic Death Capsules
Organic Death Capsules

to the family in America on who controls the dead. If no family exists, what happens then? Particularly for Western society, the state has complete ownership of the unclaimed dead. Historically, those who have been unclaimed are of lower social or economic status, such as prisoners, African slaves, immigrants, and the mentally ill. Nowadays, most unclaimed remains are cremated by request of the state.

For those who have been dead for a long amount of time, the situation gets a little more complicated. Do bioarchaeologists control the ancient dead or do long removed descendants control the ancient dead? As discussed in last week’s question on Agriculture, bioarchaeology is a vital tool in understanding past populations and the human skeleton. In America, the Native American Graves and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA) vows to repatriate indigenous human remains if tribes can provide viable proof that the remains are culturally affiliated. It also vows to protect current and future sites containing indigenous remains if culturally affiliated tribes demand it. How far back can human remains be associated with a particular group? The controversy surrounding Kennewick Man answers this question.

kennewickman
Kennewick Man

Ancient human remains, dated to be 9,200 years old, were found in Washington state in 1996. Native Americans and anthropologists disagreed on the fate of these remains. Various Native American groups tried to take ownership of these remains and did so relying on NAGPRA. Anthropologists’ wanted to study Kennewick Man extensively, because the discovery was paramount on understanding ancient migrations into the Americas. Eventually, the anthropologists’ won, so to speak, because the remains were not conclusively classified due to the time depth and lack of information as Native American in concordance with NAGPRA.

Overall, it seems that ownership of the dead dimishes as time progresses and deceased individuals share fewer and fewer genetic resemblances to a particular familial group. As for recently deceased individuals, in near cross cultural examples, the next of kin and family have control and if the remains are unclaimed, the state has control on what happens.

References:

  1. Copeland, Libby. 2015. Who owns the dead? New Repub 246(7/8):14-22.
  2. Crabtree, Jim. 2009. Emergency management and mass fatalities: who owns the dead? J Bus Cont Emerg Plan 4(1):33-46.
  3. King, Barbara. 2013. Burial rights: who owns dead bodies, anyways? NPR. http://www.npr.org/sections/13.7/2013/10/31/241840354/burial-rights-who-owns-dead-bodies-anyway.
  4. Jones, Gareth & Whitaker, Maja. 2012. Anatomy’s use of unclaimed bodies: reasons against continued dependence on an ethically dubious practice. Clin Anat 25:246-254.
  5. Lithwick, Dahlia. 2002. Habeas corpses: what are the rights of dead people? Slate. http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/jurisprudence/2002/03/habeas_corpses.html.
  6. Malik, Kenan. Who owns knowledge?: in a battle over bones, scientists and museums are losing out to the guardians of indigenous culture. Index Censor 36(3):156-167.
  7. McEvoy, Kieron & Conway, Heather. 2004. The dead, the law, and the politics of the past. J Law Soc 31(4):539-562.

If you want to know more about the death industry, here are some book suggestions:

  1. American Way of Death by Jessica Mitford
  2. Smoke Gets in Your Eyes by Caitlyn Doughty